Hollyhock House- a genius architect vs. a headstrong client
During the time Frank Lloyd Wright was continually traveling to Japan for the Imperial Hotel, one of Wright’s most prominent commissions came from oil heiress, Aline Barnsdall. Wright was asked to design the Hollyhock House, other residences and two theaters. Barnsdall envisioned a cultural center in Los Angeles.
Barnsdall v urged Wright to stretch his imagination to the limit. She wrote Frank Lloyd Wright, “ You will put your freest dreams into it. For I believe so firmly in your genius that I want to make it the keynote of my work” Is it any wonder that Wright reportedly said,” When you are a genius, it is hard to be modest”.
While Wright was planning her commission, Barnsdall was constantly traveling throughout the world. At the same time, Wright made at least ten ship voyages to Tokyo for the Imperial Hotel. They communicated by letter and telegram. Wright wrote in his Autobiography on page 227: ”
“We went to work- or I did. My client, I soon found out, had ideas and wanted yours but never worked much for long at a time, being possessed by incorrigible wanderlust that made me wonder, sometimes, what she wanted a beautiful home for, anyhow, anywhere………she would drop suggestions as a war plane drops bombs and sail away into the blue. One never knew where or from where the bombs would drop – but they dropped…… Now, with a radical client like Aline Barnsdall , a site like Olive Hill, a climate like California, an architect head on for freedom, something had to happen even by proxy. This Romanza of California had to come out on Olive Hill.”
Frank Lloyd Wright saw a great opportunity for his architectural practice in Los Angeles. Wright detested the pseudo-Spanish architecture and the representations of Italian “Renaissance” architect. Wright thought that California should have an architecture that was free of European influence. Wright believed that pre-Columbian architecture-Mayan best represented what Wright imagined as the architecture of southern California. Few houses have had the monumental devotion that Wright gave to Hollyhock House.
Wright forbid Barnsdall v from making changes during construction. Autobiography, p.229.
Frank Lloyd Wright wrote about Barnsdall and her house. “Herself a pioneer, this daughter of the pioneer lived up to integral romance when all about her was ill with pseudo-romantic in terms of neo-Spanish, lingering along as quasi-Italian, stale with Renaissance, dying or dead English half-timber and Colonial” . Wright was the American advocate for a more modern architecture.
![]() ![]() |
![]() |
||
| I |
![English acres and Broadacre model compared to a one mile grid [Sdoutz 2007] English acres and Broadacre model compared to a one mile grid [Sdoutz 2007]](http://www.mediaarchitecture.at/architekturtheorie/broadacre_city/content/broadacre_grid_overlay_800.jpg)
Quarter of Broadacre City model compared to a one mile grid composed of 640 (broad) acres at 264 x 165 feet (approx. 80 x 50 m) each.
Usonian House
In the designing the Usonian House , Frank Lloyd Wright completely revised the conception of the ideal domestic environment. The objective of the Usonian houses was to create affordable housing. Eliminating of anything unnecessary was Wright’s answer. The defining features of Wright’s design were: radiant floor heating,a single story with a flat roof and widely cantilevered eaves, floor-to-ceiling windows and doors opening to a garden with patio, a kitchen-bathroom unit slightly elevated above roof line, a bedroom zone, a kitchen-dining-living zone semi-divided by function, prefabricated walls, built-in closets, street facing clerestory windows and a carport( a term Wright invented). Wright eliminated air conditioning and as much finish work as possible. The first Usonian house was the Jacobs house in Madison,Wisconsin where the winters are cold and the summers humid.
![]() |
Wright provided the Jacobs with an open, L-shaped floor plan, laid out on a grid of two by four foot units with a total measurement of 1,550 square feet.
The masonry “core” of the house defines a small cellar which, in addition to laundry space, contains two small boilers serving the radiant heating system that circulates water through the eight inch concrete floor slab resting on a grade of packed sand. Above the cellar reside the bathroom, the open kitchen, and a fireplace, the focus of the living room. This, the largest single space of the house is reached from outside by way of a “hidden” entrance way leading from the audaciously cantilevered carport roof. At the far end of the living room a reading alcove accompanies a built-in writing table that is accommodated by a long wall of book shelves.”
Opposite these, beginning at the southeast corner, the wall of window doors opens to a graciously outlined garden shaded toward dusk by high spruce trees and terminated at the end of the bedroom wing by a corner, picnic patio.
The dining area of the house connects with the living room along the main gallery-axis and includes a long oak table designed by Wright for the space, dining chairs that he designed around 1920, and a cushioned, built-in bench. Immediately above the table, concealed lamps supplement the lengthy track lighting of 15 watt bulbs. These extend northward from the south end of the living room, past the kitchen and along enclosed storage spaces that end at the hallway leading to the bedrooms. Here the ceiling drops down to 7.5 feet from the 11.5 foot ceilings of the kitchen and bathroom and the 9.5 height of the living room and gallery.
The entire ceiling surface of the house consists of a “reflecting” design of Ponderosa pine boards and Redwood battens that echo the identical exterior and interior sides of the 2 1/4 inch thick sandwich walls. These are interspersed with red brick piers that provide the primary support of the “floating,” flat roof.
The next part will start with Fallingwater, Johnson Wax Administration Building, and Wingspread.





Mr. Tishman-
Nice series on the career of FLW. I thought you might care to know that the client for the Hollyhock House in LA was named Aline Barnsdall, not Barksdale. Thanks.
Comment by Kevin B. — March 1, 2010 @ 10:31 am
Wow! I have to agree this is very interesting. Thank you,. Crissy Walters
Comment by Tenant Background Check — June 20, 2010 @ 1:13 am
Terrific! I really believe this is right on target. Keep up with the good work! Katelynn Patterson
Comment by Tenant Screening Reports — June 21, 2010 @ 1:39 am